Project Overviews
The following examples provide a chronological overview demonstrating the scope of experience within the field of tourism research and business development . A little more detail is provided for some to show depth and variety:
Tourism Infrastructure Development Malawi
Development and upgrade of Malawi Institute of Tourism in order to provide skilled and trained personnel for the emergent tourism industry of this nation > Project funded by the Scottish Executive 2006-8.
2006-2007
Cultural Heritage Development across the BTV (Buskerud, Telemark and Vestfold) Region of Norway
This project is being undertaken on behalf of the Heyerdahl Institute, Buskerud, Telemark and Vestfold, Councils. The project aims to bring together and engage as a network private, public and voluntary sector partners involved in the development of a range of cultural heritage projects underway across the BTV region.
2005-2007
Cairnsmore of Fleet National Nature Reserve Development
This project is being undertaken on behalf of SNH. It concentrates on Cairnsmore of Fleet National Nature Reserve (NNR), which is also part of a designated Site of Special Scientific Interest (SSSI) and a Biosphere Reserves (BR) under UNESCO’s Man and Biosphere Programme. Centre staff have undertaken an audit of visitor services at Cairnsmore and are presently evaluating policy documents and reports to identify the extent and quality of learning experiences on offer. In addition they are undertaking a customer focussed longitudinal study to identify opinions and needs and to raise awareness about what services and activities are available for people living in the community and for visitors to the area. Development recommendations for making visitor services more accessible, user friendly and inclusive at Cairnsmore will also be provided. The main objective of this exercise help SNH make informed decisions to new policy objectives to improve current service delivery for visitors. The project will also contribute towards informing discussions with UNESCO to address reviewed Biosphere guidelines, which include social and economic priorities alongside those concerning conservation and preservation.
2005-2006
The Potential use of using local iconic representation and branding in the Tourism Business Development Process.
This EC funded project comes under the umbrella of the Scottish EQUAL Developing Partnerships Initiative. This project involves a comprehensive research and business development exercise set to empower and engage new businesses in an innovative training programme. It focuses attention on building entrepreneurial expertise among 20 new tourism related businesses operating within two disadvantaged rural areas in Scotland. It explores ways of doing this by applying a range of unique icons to the business development process. These identified cultural heritage icons represent famous personalities, period buildings, landscape and seascape attributes, wildlife and products which are unique to both areas. The project serves to raise awareness, among these new business operators, of the iconic significance of the locality. It aims to inspire them to improve their knowledge of and sense of pride in the area and to learn how this knowledge can be applied to develop their business potential. The idea is to explore the use icons in product branding to develop business through raising the profile of the area and increase participation in local cultural activities by residents and visitors. Training focuses on ways to use icons in product branding to develop sustainable business networks e.g. forge closer links with local heritage organisations and the wider tourism sector to achieve mutual benefits. This is facilitated by local area learning journeys and training workshops that encourage active involvement and leadership within the group to maximise impact and sustainability in the longer term. The methodology is also being discussed at a transnational level to explore ways of adapting it to suit Equal partners who represent regions in Spain and Germany.
| Moffat Centre staff also have significant experience in the design and management of large comprehensive databases including a database representing all indentified visitor attractions in the UK. This database provides a useful source of information which is relevant to this project as the following project details suggests. |
1999 to 2006
Annual National Visitor Attraction Survey Research
For the last seven years the Moffat Centre has worked on behalf of VisitScotland to compile the national statistical performance indicators on cultural tourism attractions in the form of the annual Scottish Visitor Attraction Monitor (VAM). Attractions include a range of public and private operators from large operations like National Museums and Galleries to small independent operators like Shetland Jewellery (pictured).
This nationally important research on visitor attractions performance has been undertaken for England, Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland. The Moffat Centre staff have also worked on behalf of VisitBritain, Wales Tourist Board and Northern Ireland Tourist Board to bring together all their surveys in two UK wide reports Sightseeing in the UK and Visits to UK Visitor Attractions. During this time the Centre staff were responsible for working with all national boards to improve the methodology, harmonise surveys and manage UK wide analysis. The Moffat Centre also took on board national surveys England in 2000 and for Wales (questionnaires and reports translated in English and Welsh) in 2003 while Northern Ireland gathered their own information in-house. The Moffat Centre continues to carry on visitor attraction research for Scotland and Wales and is a source of expert advice in attraction development and marketing worldwide.
2006
Dalriada Project: Brand Identity and Marketing Strategy is being undertaken on behalf of the Forestry Commission West Argyll.
The Dalriada project is in a development phase and in order to secure up to £1.8m funding from HLF a Marketing Strategy must be drafted. The Marketing Strategy will be informed by the outcomes of the research programme detailed in this proposal. The Moffat Centre undertook research to identify existing tourism product and opportunities for development, target markets and preferences for marketing activity and visitor information delivery systems, content and style be informed by the outcomes of the research undertaken by the Moffat Centre.
2006
North West Highlands Geopark Marketing Plan was undertaken on behalf of Caithness and Sutherland Enterprise.
This project involved an area audit, evaluation and development of a Marketing Plan to cover the period of initial funding for the Geo Park to 2008. The objectives were to: identify the key elements of the North West Highland Geopark tourism product; recommend the most appropriate routes to potential market segments for the Geopark's products; create a realistic, time-framed action plan for the delivery of the above recommendations, including an assessment of the most appropriate deliverers of actions and to recommend an effective monitoring framework for all marketing activities.
2005-2006
Church Marshes Country Park Audience Development Plan was undertaken on behalf of Swale Borough District Council. The project involved the provision of a feasibility study for transforming the derelict Church Marshes landscape into a sustainable country park. Tasks involved consultation with a range of expert stakeholders representing local, regional and national policy interests. Stakeholders included people representing natural heritage conservation, rural recreation, community education and visitor attractions. The project considered a range of issues including natural heritage conservation, the development of onsite heritage attractions, visitor service provision, community involvement, and countryside related education.
This project involved providing recommendations for the sustainable development of this amenity as a cultural landscape for the use of local people and visitors to the area. The aims of the project are to develop tourism potential and encourage more recreational use within this locality in activities such as cultural heritage related education, walking and cycling. The project involved a serious of successful workshops which raised awareness and involved a diverse range of community representatives and stakeholders in the planning and decision making process for this proposed development.
2002 - 2006
(1) Burns Festival Impact Assessment 2002-2006 has been undertaken annually on behalf of Scottish Enterprise Ayrshire since 2002.
It served to assess the economic impact of the Burns and a’ Festival and initially provided a framework for replicating the impact assessment year on year. The project also served to Raise awareness of Robert Burns and contemporary Scottish culture, and provide a positive platform for the attraction of private sponsorship in future years.
(2) Towards 2009: Burns National Audit and Economic Impact Study was undertaken on behalf of Scottish Enterprise Ayrshire. It identified the scale and importance of the Robert Burns brand and the significance of the ‘bard’s identity nationally and internationally. The main objective was to produce a sustainable action plan for the 2009 homecoming with identified budget and proposed development opportunities.
(3) Burns Humanitarian Award Options Appraisal involved a comprehensive interview and benchmarking exercise to provide recommendations for the development of the Burns Humanitarian Award which up until 2006 was part of the Burns Festival opening event.
2005-2006
Tourism SMEs business development Profit Through Productivity (Wales, Suffolk, NW England)
The Moffat Centre is a registered and established UK Department of Trade and Industry provider of Business development Assistance to Tourism Businesses throughout the UK. This project involves Business development, Marketing and Sales advice and Mentoring and Profit Improvement targeting mainly visitor attraction and accommodation businesses. In 2005 the project provided partnership assistance for 25 of the largest visitor attractions in Suffolk. Similar assistance purely in the visitor attraction Sector has been provided in North Wales for some 23 businesses. The Moffat Centre continues to work with small businesses under the PTP programme.
2005
Realising the True Impact of Museums and Art Galleries in Scottish Tourism.
This comprehensive research project was undertaken on behalf of the Scottish Museums Council to inform the Scottish Executive’s Cultural Commission’s report ‘Our Next Major Enterprise’ Report which was published in June 2005 (See section 16.15.2 sub-heading Marketing, promotion and links to tourism on http://www.scotland.gov.uk/Publications/2005/09/0191729/18061
The impact study examined the contribution museums and galleries make to the tourism and cultural infrastructure of Scotland. The project tackled in some detail a critique of the definition of cultural heritage, identified the iconic significance of museums. The summary and full report are published online on http://www.scottishmuseums.org.uk
2005
The Business Case for a Visitor Centre at Glasgow Botanic Garden.
This study provided a business plan and guidance to Scottish Enterprise Glasgow to ensure that the new Botanic Garden facility provides visitors with a successful and enjoyable experience while at the same time realising a financially secure future.
2005
Scottish Borders: Tourism Strategy undertaken on behalf of VisitScotland (Borders). This Strategy was developed to replace its former Tourism Strategy (1999-2004) to cover the period 2006-2009. This project was two-fold. A desk-based research exercise was first undertaken to identify critical structural and market changes within tourism to help the Partnership establish a clear strategic direction and vision for the future along with a SWOT evaluation of tourism performance in the Borders. Secondly, a consultation exercise was undertaken via a number of workshops with both public and private sector representation to ensure cohesiveness, buy-in and relevance of findings and preliminary recommendations drawn from the first phase.
2004
Evaluation of Macdonald Sisters Display destined for refurbished Kelvigrove Museum and Art Gallery.
This project involved an audit of new displays and effectiveness of access to a wide range of user groups including school children, partially sighted, English as second language, non-expert visitors and tourists. Interviews, participant observation and intercept surveys were used to acquire information.
2004
Tayside Food Study was commissioned by Scottish Enterprise Tayside to carry out a
critical review of food initiatives and activities with actual or potential impact on tourism. This built on a study undertaken by the Moffat Centre on behalf of Scottish Enterprise National in 2002.
2004
Developing Competitive Advantage: Paisley Museum and Observatory was
commissioned by the Renfrewshire Museums Service to review the revenue generation potential of Paisley Museums and Art Galleries and Coats Observatory. Particular emphasis was placed on the development of quality visitor services and interpretation. Paisley Museum textile industrial Coates whose Paisley mill (pictured) developed and produced the internationally renowned Paisley pattern design.
2004
Royal Botanic Gardens, Edinburgh sales/revenue forecasting and planning project.
This project involved providing recommendations for the commercial development of visitor services at the Royal Botanic Gardens.
2004
The Relocation of the Glenlee from Glasgow Harbour to Pointhouse Project was funded by Glasgow Council on behalf of the Clyde Maritime Trust. This project is part of a major riverside development underway on the banks of the River Clyde.
The aim of this project was to review and provide recommendations for day-time commercial revenue generation when the Glenlee (the Tall Ship at Glasgow Harbour) relocates to the Pointhouse Quay area in the proximity of the new Riverside Museum of Transport.
2004
Skills Training to Facilitate Access by Community Groups to Cultural Resources held in museums, art galleries, libraries and archives was commissioned by the City of Edinburgh Council, Scottish Executive and the Scottish Museums Council. This was a nationwide project managed by a high profile stakeholder steering group involved in a range community learning and development leadership roles. The project addressed new lifelong learning policy priorities and involved widespread consultation with people delivering a broad range of community education across Scotland. These included tutors leading community education training in Further Education and Higher Education institutions; public sector and voluntary sector managers and community leaders involved in adult learning and youth services; community librarians; museum and art gallery educators and students studying community education/learning and development programmes. Methods of gathering information to identify skills gaps included interviews backed up by questionnaire surveys targeting a broad range of educators, trainees and students of community learning and development education. This project was ahead of its time and produced training materials to be delivered by further and higher education institutions across Scotland.
2004
The Lighthouse, Glasgow hospitality and catering review was undertaken to provide recommendations to inform the development of existing provision.
2003
Review of the 12 Leading National Trust for Scotland Visitor Attractions & Assessment of Performance of Key Competitors.
This project was undertaken on behalf of the National Trust for Scotland. It involved an audit of the Trusts 12 leading properties and benchmarking exercise identifying examples of best practice. The report identified the thematic aspects of operation/revenue potential and visitor journey reform necessary for the 12 properties; and a brief prioritised action plan for each property.
This project was undertaken in order to provide realistic business development scenarios for these 12 important heritage properties. Comparative analysis of competitors was conducted on leading UK attractions to provide systematic targets that were measurable for revenue, profitability, quality, service etc. Revenue generation plans were developed for the leading 12 properties. A review of all commercial operations in these properties was undertaken and recommendations using best practice examples were provided to make provision more effective.
2003
Attractions of Snowdonia Wales: Visitor Attractions Audit and Development Project involved an audit and quality assessment of visitor attractions in Snowdonia. Operators were provided with advice and a benchmarking learning journey of best practice operations elsewhere in the UK.
2003
Duthie Park Development Strategy.
Historically, Aberdeen’s Duthie Park and Winter Gardens (DPWG) has been an important cultural icon for both visitors to and residents of Aberdeen. The redevelopment of the park was required to significantly increase visitation by local communities, host populations and leisure visitors. As there were little existing visitor statistics new data collection methods were developed to build valuable visitor/consumer data. In order to achieve this staff in the Park were trained on how to perform intercept surveys. The development of a marketing plan and sales orientation for operation was created in order to maximise yields and increase the quality of the visitor experience
2003
International Learning Journey Canadian Rockies - The Moffat Centre has also been at the cutting edge in the development of Learning from best practice at a practical level. Recently an International Learning Journey has been delivered on behalf of Highlands and Islands Enterprise contrasting rural Scotland with the Canadian Rockies in 2003. This included an intensive visit to Canada where meetings and ‘mentor led’ development occurred with approximately 40 tourism representatives (Client: Highlands and Enterprise).
2003
Attractions of Snowdonia Learning Journey
This is a two part review of best practice and the development of competitive exemplars being conducted for this active consortium of visitor attractions in North Wales. This has involved looking at outstanding attractions that can provide clear indications of how to develop in identified areas such as: family based marketing, seasonal extension, spend on site, developing profitable events, growing corporate hospitality etc. The lessons are provided via arranged field trips to quality exemplars with briefing and ‘behind the scenes’ guidance for operators
2003
Galloway Forest Park (GFP) Visitor Opinion Survey
This comprehensive project involved the design of appropriate questionnaires targeting a range of users and non-users of Galloway Forest Park. This resulted in a year long longitudinal seasonal intercept survey of visitors to GFP and nearby towns. The survey targeted the three Forestry Commission visitor centres, other popular locations within GFP and a town based street intercept. Tourism information centres in towns nearby and local accommodation businesses were provided with a supply of self-complete surveys. Intercept surveys were undertaken from March until October when the visitor centres closed for the winter. The purpose of the survey was to provide:
o An analysis of visitor attitudes and expectations concerning activities, facilities and service quality provided at GFP and through visitor centres.
o An analysis of general Park awareness, effectiveness of signage and knowledge of range of activities available in the Galloway Forest Park.
o An understanding of gaps in demand in terms of the Forest product and services and an appreciation of how well the Park is utilised by the sample surveyed.
Information to strengthen Forest Enterprise's case for funding to help the Scottish Executive meet their objectives in Rural Development, social inclusion and health improvement.
2003
Tourism Scenario Planning
In 2003 the Moffat Centre in partnership with VisitScotland have developed a range of Tourism Indicators, Forecasts and Scenario Models that are providing the basis for future policy and planning at an NTO level. They will provide key data and forecasts forward to 5 years and represent some of the most advanced work anywhere in the world in this field (Joint research project with VisitScotland)
1997-2003
Scottish Enterprise (SE) Renfrewshire; SE Forth Valley and SE Ayrshire Hospitality Business Development
The Moffat Centre delivered Tourism Advisory Services on behalf of Scottish Enterprise Renfrewshire. Several hospitality projects have been undertaken with clients including:
We have significant experience in collating output data such as economic and quality improvements. We are familiar with the IFSO and output monitoring framework used by LECs.
Consultancy support undertaken on behalf of Scottish Enterprise Forth Valley [1998-2001] include establishments such as Monachyle Mhor Hotel and Restaurant, Culcreuch Castle, and Granger Manor Hotel (website development). As a Business Advisor on behalf of Scottish Enterprise Dunbartonshire Tourism High Growth Programme, support was provided for Coach House Coffee Shop [2001-2]. Under the Scottish Enterprise Ayrshire consultancy contract for supporting the Small Business Gateway programme [2001-2] a number of establishments have received support including Fouters Bistro Restaurant, Blairquhan Estate, and Glegwhittle Tea Room.
2002
Volunteering in the National Trust for Scotland
An exploration of volunteer support in the National Trust for Scotland (NTS) involved a comprehensive survey of volunteers working in historic buildings, countryside properties and shops which were managed by the NTS.
2002
Food and Tourism Cluster Initiative
The Moffat Centre was requested by the Scottish Enterprise, Highlands and Islands Enterprise to undertake a major analysis of the area of food and tourism. The Food and Tourism Cluster Initiative assessed successful examples of overseas food festivals and events that provide competitive exemplars.
2000-2002
Edinburgh Zoo
This project involved a review of catering provision across the zoo, a detailed analysis of financial statements, and service and menu development. Further support was provided towards the distribution of a tender specification document to outside suppliers, and a subsequent interview selection process.
2002
Redevelopment of Kelvingrove Museum Services on behalf of Glasgow Council’s Leisure and Cultural Services Department.
This project involved working with the planning steering group and providing recommendations for commercial service provision within the transformed Kelvingrove development.
2001
Benchmarking and Competitor Analysis National and Regional Park Development
A review and best practice comparison exercise was undertaken to consider how Scottish Regional Parks should develop and build on their huge potential urban catchment areas in order to drive usage and access. Comparable National and Regional Park situations were analysed and compared in the UK and Ireland in order to provide a clear development plan for the client park (Client: Clyde Muirshiel Regional Park, Scottish Enterprise Renfrewshire)
2000
An Analysis of Ayr Town Trail Development was undertaken on behalf of South Ayrshire Council.
This project appraised the potential impact of this proposed 14 stop Heritage Trail that passed through Ayr town centre. The route focussed on built heritage and Scottish heritage personalities including James Watt the inventor, Robert Burns the poet and David Wilkie the painter (all pictured on wall of Ayr Academy). Recommendations considered the potential economic impact of such a trail on local businesses, tourism and the local economy. It also considered proposed trail route, attraction linkages and generic branding and provided best practice recommendations for interpretative signage and business development.
2000
St John’s Tower Ayr Evaluation and Appraisal was undertaken on behalf of South Ayrshire Council.
This feasibility study involved an audit and appraisal of the potential market for the proposed development of St. John’s Tower, Ayr as a visitor attraction. Issues considered included its role in natural/built heritage conservation and education, capacity and health and safety. It also considered the impact of a redeveloped tower on tourism to Ayr and the amalgam of visitor attractions within the town. Consultation was undertaken with a broad stakeholder group.
2000
Callander Food Initiative
The Centre has co-developed and delivered alongside Mo Scott (Earlshill Farm Foods, and previous owner of Poachers Restaurant, which was awarded a Michelin Red M). This initiative focused on food costing, presentation styles, and marketing whilst encouraging the use of local, Scottish produce. The Initiative was delivered to prepare tourism operators for the opening of the Loch Lomond National Park [2001-2]. The success of this initiative has recently led to the commissioning of a similar programme in and around the Aberfoyle region [2002-3].
2000
Finlaystone Country Estate
Long-term business development support for this growing estate managed by the family of the Chief of the Clan MacMillan. Support has been provided towards catering provision (currently franchised), staff development, marketing and promotion through development of a family of brochures, web-site, Thistle Award Application, etc.
2000
Sandyholm Garden Centre and Coffee Shop
Business development support including a Business Development Review, guidance and support towards the redevelopment of the coffee shop within one of Clyde Valley’s longest established and largest garden centres. The new 200+ seater shop includes indoor and outdoor seating, and has been designed to complement the theme of fresh local produce using a design of glass and horticulture. The coffee shop menu relies on home-baking and traditional recipes, with a clear absence of fried foods.
2001-2002
Glasgow Museums Catering Review
This review of catering provision across some of Glasgow’s key museum and galleries, undertaken on behalf of Glasgow City Council. This project involved primary research through intercept surveys, benchmarking against international attractions, and undertaking quality assessments of units.
1999
Skills Forecasting Scotland: A Labour Market Analysis of the Scottish Cultural Heritage, Arts and Entertainment Sectors.
This comprehensive project was undertaken on behalf of the Cultural Heritage National Training Organisation and Metier. It sampled and analysed through surveys and interviewing the state of the labour market and skills needs and shortages in training in the Cultural Heritage and Arts and Entertainment sectors.
1999
Development Opportunities for Non-Vehicular Walking Route Located in the Scottish Borders.
This project was undertaken on behalf of the Scottish Borders Tourist Board and aimed to provide recommendations for the development of the Borders Abbeys Way heritage walk. This circular footpath touched on four significant Borders ancient heritage sites, i.e. Dryburgh Abbey (pictured), Melrose Abbey, Jedburgh Abbey, Kelso Abbey. http://www.bordersabbeysway.fsnet.co.uk/
The fragile state of the rural economy in the Scottish Borders had led to greater dependence on tourism. Hence, the aims and objectives of this research were concerned primarily with tourism development issues. Recommendations served to identify opportunities appropriate to the development of a range of walking market segments for the Borders Abbeys Way Footpath and other related services and facilities.
1998
Café Gandolfi Group
– long-term business development support towards the growth of the group. This included the introduction of catering provision in the Habitat retail store (Buchanan Galleries, Glasgow), the purchase of the original premises from a lease, and significant support towards marketing, promotion and press [1998-current].
1997
The Willow Tea Rooms Group
– long-term business development support for this growing company which includes the original tea room in Sauchiehall Street which is located within the original Charles Rennie Mackintosh/ Kate Cranston tea room (and remains a visitor attraction in its own right). The Group also operates at the larger Buchanan Street location which is located over 3 floors, and has an outside catering function. The Group has been successful in achieving press and promotion whilst retaining a focus on staff development, and has been awarded Investors in People (IIP).
1999
New Horizons International Benchmarking and Best Practice for Visitor Attractions 1999. Scottish Enterprise
In 1998 Professor Lennon worked with Professor Tony Seaton from the Scottish Tourism Research Unit on a benchmarking study funded by Scottish Enterprise.
This project identified 10 important tourism destinations which included Canada, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Netherlands, Norway, the Republic of Ireland, Singapore and USA. The study generated 10 visitor attraction case study examples of best practice. This included examples where
cultural and heritage was presented in an innovative way.
1998-1999
Urban Tourism Performance – Competitor Analysis Dublin and Glasgow
This project considered key lessons from the growth and success of Dublin as an urban tourism destination and considered the role of key agencies such as NTOs, Convention Bureaus, Development funding etc. This 12 month period of analysis explored public and private sector development in both cities in order to best understand from a Scottish perspective key lessons to be taken from the Irish model.
1997
New Horizons – International Benchmarking and Best Practice in Visitor Attractions –
Professor Lennon was a co-author of this influential work on visitor attraction competitor analysis. A full summary of the report is available on www.scotexchange.net and is one of the most downloaded reports held on the site. Professor Lennon undertook competitor analysis of leading attractions in the USA, Singapore, Germany, Ireland and the UK with a view to providing development guidance for the visitor attractions industry in Scotland (Client: Scottish Enterprise).
Updated:
3 October, 2007
| Site
editor | Legal
|